Reference

Questions before you rely on an exchange

Use this as a list of questions for a qualified intermediary and a tax advisor. It is not a sequence that makes an exchange qualify, and it is not a set of instructions for closing one.

Checking a box on a website does nothing. This is general information, not tax, legal, or financial advice. A real exchange needs a qualified intermediary and a tax advisor.

About the property you would transfer

  • Is it real property held for business or investment, rather than for personal use?
  • If you live there, why do you think it is anything other than a primary home, which is not the typical case?
  • If it is a dwelling you also use yourself, have you looked at the rental and personal-use conditions in the vacation-home safe harbor, instead of assuming they fit?
  • After the 2017 tax law, are you relying on real property only, and not on personal property?

About what you would receive

  • Is the replacement U.S. real property that you will hold for business or investment?
  • Are you sure it is not foreign real property, which is not like-kind to U.S. real property?
  • Can you identify it in writing within 45 days under the three-property rule, the 200 percent rule, or the 95 percent rule?
  • Can you receive it by the earlier of 180 days after the transfer or your tax-return due date, including extensions?

About the money

  • Will a qualified intermediary hold the proceeds so you never have receipt or control, including constructive receipt?
  • Is that intermediary independent — not your agent, attorney, accountant, or a related disqualified person?
  • If you want to defer the whole gain, is the replacement of equal or greater value, and will you replace debt that is paid off?
  • If you plan to keep cash or other non-like-kind value, do you understand that the boot is generally taxable?

About the people and the state

  • Is the same taxpayer on both sides, once title, entities, and any single-member LLC are taken into account?
  • Is a related person buying or selling, which can bring in the two-year holding rule and the cash-out limit under section 1031(f)?
  • Has a tax advisor told you whether your state follows federal 1031 treatment? Some do not, and a state return can still show tax.
  • If someone has mentioned a DST or a TIC interest, have you treated that as a separate, fact-specific question rather than as a generic replacement property?